Choosing a car shipping company is not like ordering a pizza. You are handing over a vehicle worth thousands — sometimes tens of thousands — of dollars to a company you have never met, and trusting it will arrive at the other end undamaged, on time, and without surprise fees. The auto transport industry has over 7,000 registered brokers, and the quality gap between the best and the worst is enormous. As a licensed broker ourselves, we know exactly what separates a reliable operation from one that will take your deposit and disappear into a voicemail abyss. This checklist is built from the broker’s side of the desk — seven concrete steps you can take before you book, using only free public tools and the contract in front of you.

The 7-Point Broker Vetting Checklist

1. Verify the FMCSA License — Before You Share an Email Address

Every legitimate auto transport broker in the United States must hold a Motor Carrier (MC) number issued by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration. This is not optional — it is federal law under 49 CFR Part 371. The broker is also required to post their MC number on their website and in any advertising. When you land on a car shipping company’s website, look for the MC number (usually in the footer or on an “About” page). Then go to the FMCSA SAFER Company Snapshot and enter it. You will instantly see: whether the authority type says “Broker” (not just “Carrier” — a carrier without broker authority cannot legally arrange shipments for other carriers), whether the authority is “Active,” and whether the broker carries the required 75,000 dollar surety bond or trust fund. If the MC number returns “Not Authorized,” “Inactive,” or belongs to an entity that only has carrier authority, close the tab and move on. This single check takes 60 seconds and eliminates roughly 20 percent of operators — the ones running without valid authority. We have a detailed step-by-step walkthrough with screenshots in our FMCSA license verification guide.

2. Verify the Carrier’s Insurance — Do Not Take the Broker’s Word for It

A licensed auto transport carrier is required to carry cargo insurance, but the minimum federal requirement is only 750,000 dollars in coverage — and that is spread across every vehicle on the truck, not per car. If a ten-car hauler carries 750,000 dollars in cargo coverage and is fully loaded with ten vehicles worth 50,000 dollars each, that is 500,000 dollars of exposure on 750,000 dollars of coverage. The math works. But put one six-figure luxury SUV on that same truck and the per-vehicle math changes fast. When you are vetting a broker, ask for the carrier’s insurance certificate — not the broker’s contingent cargo policy, which is secondary coverage that only kicks in if the carrier’s insurance fails to pay. Ask for the carrier’s policy directly. Then call the insurance provider listed on the certificate and verify the policy is active. A broker who will not share the carrier’s insurance details before you book is a red flag. For a full breakdown of what is covered and what is excluded, read our car shipping insurance guide.

3. Know What Kind of Quote You Are Looking At

Most car shipping quotes are non-binding estimates. That means the number you see is a market snapshot — what the broker expects a carrier to accept at that moment. The final price can (and often does) change once a carrier actually bids on your shipment. A binding quote, by contrast, locks in a guaranteed price before you commit. Binding quotes are less common because they transfer pricing risk from you to the broker — if carrier rates spike between the quote and pickup day, the broker eats the difference. Here is the key vetting point: ask the broker explicitly whether the quote is binding or non-binding, and get the answer in writing. If the broker hems and haws, uses language like “this is what it should be” or “prices are subject to change,” you are looking at a non-binding estimate — and you should budget 10 to 20 percent above the quote for the final price. Legitimate brokers will tell you which type of quote they are offering without needing to be pressed. Our guide to binding vs non-binding quotes explains the difference in detail.

4. Cross-Check Reviews Across Three Platforms

Google reviews are the most visible — and the most manipulated. A 4.9-star rating with 200 generic five-star reviews that all say “great service, on time delivery” is not a sign of a great broker. It is a sign of a review-buying operation. When vetting a car shipping company, check at least three review platforms: Google, the Better Business Bureau (BBB), and Transport Reviews (transportreviews.com, the auto-transport-specific review site). Look for patterns: do complaints mention the same problem over and over (deposit disputes, bait-and-switch pricing, carrier no-shows)? Are negative reviews met with a copy-paste apology template? A broker with a 4.2 average across three platforms and detailed, specific responses to complaints is far more trustworthy than a 4.9 on Google alone. We published a complete guide to spotting fake auto transport reviews with platform-by-platform verification steps.

5. Read the Contract Before You Give Payment Information

This sounds obvious, yet a staggering number of people book car shipping without reading the contract. Here are the five specific clauses to find before you sign: (1) the cancellation policy — can you cancel without penalty before a carrier is assigned? After? (2) the deposit refund terms — is the deposit refundable, partially refundable, or non-refundable, and under what conditions? (3) the delivery window — is it defined in calendar days or “estimated business days”? (4) the price adjustment clause — does the contract reserve the right to raise the price after pickup for any reason? And (5) the dispute resolution clause — does it require binding arbitration in the broker’s home state, effectively making it impossible for you to sue? A contract without clear answers to all five of these questions is not a contract you should sign. We catalogued the seven most common contract traps in our car shipping contract red flags guide.

6. Understand the Deposit — How Much Is Normal and What It Actually Pays For

A deposit of 100 to 350 dollars is standard in auto transport. This is not a random fee — it covers the broker’s cost of dispatching your shipment: matching your vehicle to a carrier, verifying the carrier’s insurance and safety record, and coordinating the pickup window. What is not normal: deposits over 500 dollars, demands for full payment upfront before a carrier is even assigned, or brokers who cannot explain what the deposit covers. Also note: most car shipping deposits are non-refundable once a carrier has been assigned, because the broker has already done the work — the dispatch cost is sunk. A broker who promises a “fully refundable deposit no matter what” may be telling you what you want to hear rather than what is actually enforceable. For the full picture on deposits, including what happens when you cancel, see our guides on zero-deposit car shipping claims and deposit refund policies.

7. Ask These Five Questions Before You Book

The final vetting step is the one most people skip: a five-minute phone call. Even if you plan to book online, call the broker and ask these questions. How they answer — not just what they say, but whether they answer directly or deflect — tells you more than any review:

  1. “What is your MC number, and can I see your carrier’s insurance certificate before I book?” — A legitimate broker answers this in seconds.
  2. “Is this quote binding or non-binding, and what could cause the final price to change?” — Listen for a clear, confident answer, not hedging.
  3. “What happens if the carrier does not show up during the pickup window?” — The answer should include a specific re-dispatch process with a timeline, not “that never happens.”
  4. “Can you send me a copy of the contract to review before I pay anything?” — If the answer is anything other than “yes, here you go,” walk away.
  5. “What happens if my car arrives with damage — who do I call, and what is the claims process?” — There should be a named process, not a vague “we will take care of it.”

Frequently Asked Questions About Choosing a Car Shipping Company

How do I verify if a car shipping broker is licensed?

Visit the FMCSA SAFER Company Snapshot at safer.fmcsa.dot.gov and enter the broker’s MC number, which you can usually find in the website footer. Check three things: the authority type should say “Broker” (not just “Carrier”), the status should say “Active,” and the broker must carry the required 75,000 dollar surety bond or trust fund. If the MC number returns “Not Authorized” or the entity only has carrier authority, do not use that broker. The lookup is free, takes 60 seconds, and eliminates the most dangerous operators instantly.

What is the difference between a binding and non-binding car shipping quote?

A non-binding quote is a market estimate — the final price can change once a carrier actually bids on your shipment. Most car shipping quotes are non-binding, and the final price typically lands 10 to 20 percent above the initial quote. A binding quote locks in a guaranteed price upfront, transferring pricing risk from you to the broker. Binding quotes are less common because the broker absorbs any cost increase between the quote and pickup day. Always ask explicitly which type you are receiving and get the answer in writing before you pay.

How much deposit is normal for car shipping?

A deposit of 100 to 350 dollars is standard in auto transport. This money covers the broker’s cost of dispatching your shipment: matching your vehicle to a carrier, verifying insurance and safety records, and coordinating the pickup window. Deposits over 500 dollars, demands for full payment before a carrier is assigned, or a broker who cannot explain what the deposit covers are all red flags. Most car shipping deposits are non-refundable once a carrier has been assigned, because the dispatch work has already been performed.

What are the biggest red flags when choosing a car shipping company?

The biggest red flags include: an invalid or missing MC number, refusal to share the carrier’s insurance certificate before booking, deposit demands over 500 dollars, pressure to pay in full upfront before a carrier is assigned, contracts that lack a clear cancellation policy or delivery window, and a pattern of identical five-star Google reviews with no substance. Always cross-check reviews across Google, the Better Business Bureau, and Transport Reviews (transportreviews.com) — not just one platform.

We built this checklist because we compete in the same market as brokers who skip every step on it. The auto transport industry suffers from a visibility problem: the lowest-price quote almost always comes from the broker who does the least vetting. When you choose a car shipping company, you are not just buying transportation — you are buying the broker’s judgment about which carrier to trust with your vehicle. The seven steps above are free, take under 30 minutes total, and will filter out the bottom third of the market before you hand over a credit card number. If you want to compare quotes from brokers who have already been vetted against these standards, get a free quote from Best Care Auto Transport or call us at (224) 414-2700. We are a licensed and bonded broker (MC-1646663) with a 4.8-star rating across 105 verified Google reviews, headquartered in Elk Grove Village, Illinois — not a virtual office, not a PO box, and not a call center that subcontracts to whoever answers the phone.